For sellers

Appraisal lower than purchase price?What happens to a firm deal in Canada

The appraisal came in short and the deal is firm. The buyer still owes every dollar, but the seller is the one who waits.

Short answer: A low appraisal does not change a firm deal in Canada. Once the buyer has waived the financing condition (Ontario and most provinces) or removed subjects (British Columbia), they owe the full purchase price on closing day, even when the appraisal is lower than the purchase price. The lender simply lends less, so the buyer has to cover the gap in cash, find another lender, or ask the seller for a better deal.

That last part is where sellers get pulled in. A short appraisal rarely ends with a buyer walking away on the spot. Far more often it ends with a phone call from the buyer's agent asking for more time, a lower price, or both. The contract hasn't changed, but the seller's plans suddenly depend on how fast someone else can find money.

Why would an appraisal come in lower than the purchase price?

A lender's appraisal is a valuation of the home on the current market, ordered to protect the lender, not the buyer. When prices are softening, an appraiser working from recent sales can land below a price that was agreed weeks or months earlier.

That's the setup right now. CREA reported that the national MLS Home Price Index was down 3.4% year over year in September 2026, the first time since January that the annual decline grew larger. On October 28, 2026, the Bank of Canada raised its policy rate to 2.5% and said there could be a need to raise it further.

Softer prices and higher borrowing costs are the classic recipe for an appraisal gap. Long closings add to it, because the longer the wait between firm and closing, the more the market can move underneath the price.

Can a buyer back out if the appraisal is low and the deal is firm?

No, not without consequences. The buyer's protection against a short appraisal was the financing condition, and once that condition is waived, the risk belongs to the buyer.

The wording differs by province, but the result is the same:

  • Ontario and most provinces: the buyer includes a financing condition, then waives it in writing to make the deal firm. After that, the buyer is bound to close at the agreed price. Our guide to waiving the financing condition explains what each waiver gives up.
  • British Columbia: the buyer writes "subject to financing" into the contract, then removes subjects in writing. The BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA) warns that if financing a buyer believed they qualified for falls through after the offer goes subject-free, the buyer could forfeit the deposit and/or face a lawsuit from the seller.

An Ontario case shows how this plays out. In Deco Homes (Richmond Hill) Inc. v. Serikov, 2021 ONSC 2079, the buyer's lender appraised the property about $300,000 below the $1,248,380 price shortly before closing. The buyer could not make up the shortfall and failed to close. The court let the seller keep the $120,915.30 deposit and awarded $154,164.26 in additional damages. (The seller in that case was a builder, so we use it here as a legal illustration only. Home Closing Insurance covers resale homes, not new builds.)

How does a buyer cover an appraisal gap before closing day?

Lenders lend against the lower of the purchase price or the appraised value. So when the appraisal is lower than the purchase price, the mortgage shrinks, and every dollar of the gap comes out of the buyer's pocket.

Here is a modelled example using CREA's national average home price of $666,538 for September 2026, a conventional mortgage at 80% of value, and an appraisal 5% below the price ($633,211):

PlannedAfter a 5% low appraisal
Purchase price$666,538$666,538
Mortgage at 80%$533,230$506,569
Buyer's cash to close (before closing costs)$133,308$159,969

In other words, the buyer needs to find $26,661 more than they planned, on top of land transfer tax, legal fees and adjustments. Usually they have three ways to do it:

  1. Bring more cash. Savings, a line of credit or help from family. Fastest if the money exists.
  2. Change lenders. A B lender or private lender may lend more, but usually at a higher cost, and a new lender means a new approval, sometimes a new appraisal, and time.
  3. Ask the seller. A lower price, a vendor take-back mortgage, or more time to close.

Options two and three both cost time. That's why a short appraisal so often turns into a request to move the closing date.

Can the buyer ask the seller to lower the price or move the closing date?

The buyer can ask. The seller doesn't have to agree: a firm agreement binds both sides at the agreed price and closing date, and changing either one takes a written amendment both parties sign.

So the request is a negotiation, not a right. But a seller who says no is betting the buyer will find the money in time. If the buyer can't, the seller's next home, moving date and bridge financing are all waiting on a closing that may not happen.

Before you answer your buyer: see what a failed closing actually costs a Canadian seller, line by line, in the real cost of a failed home closing in Canada.

My buyer's appraisal came in low. What are my options as a seller?

Every top result for this question is written for the buyer. Here is the seller's side. When the buyer comes back short, a seller usually has three choices.

1. Agree to a price cut. It can save the closing, but it is money off your sale. If the buyer's next lender or a future buyer's lender is likely to land in the same place, a cut may be the realistic number. Talk to your real estate agent about recent comparable sales before you decide.

2. Agree to an extension. This is the most common answer, and it is a request for more time that lands on your calendar. While the buyer hunts for cash or a new lender, you keep paying the mortgage, property taxes, utilities and insurance. If you've bought your next home, you may be carrying two properties or paying for bridge financing. Get any extension in writing through your lawyer, and know that a buyer who needed more time once may need it again.

3. Hold firm and expect the buyer to close. That is your legal right. If the buyer closes, you're done. If they don't, you have a buyer in default, and the path from there runs through the deposit, a re-listing and possibly a lawsuit.

What happens to the deposit if the buyer can't close because of a low appraisal?

The deposit doesn't move quickly. It's held in trust and is usually released only by agreement of both sides or a court order. It also rarely covers the loss.

Look again at Deco Homes. The closing failed in March 2019. The seller re-listed and resold for $980,800, which is $267,580 below the original price, and the court judgment came in 2021, about two years later. The seller won, kept the deposit and was awarded damages, but carried the gap for roughly two years to get there.

That's the part most coverage of low appraisals skips. A low appraisal is the buyer's legal problem and the seller's cash-flow problem. The law sits on the seller's side. The money doesn't arrive on the seller's schedule.

How can sellers and real estate agents reduce appraisal risk before a firm offer?

A few steps help before the deal goes firm:

  • Price from recent sales, not last spring's. In a falling market, comparable sales from even a few months ago can overstate value.
  • Ask how the buyer is financing. A buyer with a small down payment and no cushion is more exposed to a short appraisal than a buyer with room to spare.
  • Watch long closings. The more time between firm and closing, the more the market can shift before the lender's appraisal or a re-appraisal.
  • Protect the gap itself. Home Closing Insurance covers the part of the deal the deposit and the courts handle slowly.

Home Closing Insurance from SecureMyOffer protects you, the seller, as the insured party, when a buyer delays or fails to close on a firm sale. If your claim is covered, it pays your lawyer to pursue the buyer and advances the buyer's deposit while you wait. Depending on the plan, it can also cover carrying and relisting costs (Essentials Plus and Comprehensive) and a lower resale price (Comprehensive), up to a maximum of $250,000 per policy. It is not a promise that your buyer will close. It protects your finances if they don't. Coverage is subject to the policy's terms, limits and exclusions.

You can apply while your closing date is more than 15 days away, and you pay once, after your sale is firm. It's available for resale homes across Canada, except Quebec.

Questions people ask

What happens if the bank appraisal is lower than the purchase price?

The lender lends against the lower appraised value, so the buyer gets a smaller mortgage and must make up the difference. On a firm deal, the buyer still owes the full purchase price on closing day. If they can't cover the gap, they risk losing the deposit and being sued for the seller's losses.

Can a buyer walk away from a firm deal because of a low appraisal?

Not without consequences. Once the financing condition is waived in Ontario, or subjects are removed in BC, the buyer is bound to close. In Deco Homes v. Serikov (2021), a buyer whose appraisal came in about $300,000 short lost a $120,915.30 deposit and was ordered to pay $154,164.26 more.

Does the seller have to lower the price after a low appraisal?

No. A firm agreement binds both sides at the agreed price, and changing it takes an amendment both parties sign. A seller may still choose to negotiate if it saves the closing.

What should a seller do when the buyer's appraisal comes in low?

Talk to your real estate agent and lawyer before you answer. Your options are a price cut, an extension or holding firm, and each one has a cost. Get any change in writing, and plan for the closing date moving.

Will the deposit cover my losses if the buyer can't close?

Usually not on its own, and not quickly. The deposit stays in trust until both sides agree or a court orders its release, and a resale at a lower price, carrying costs and legal fees can add up to far more than the deposit.

Appraisal lower than purchase price: the bottom line for sellers

When the appraisal is lower than the purchase price on a firm deal, the buyer owes the full price, and the seller often ends up waiting while the buyer finds it. Know your options before the call comes, and read when your buyer won't close: a Canadian seller's options for what happens if the buyer never does.

A firm deal settles who owes the money; it doesn't settle when it arrives.


This article is general information, not legal, financial or insurance advice. Coverage depends on the terms, limits, exclusions and conditions of the policy or surety issued.